Navigating the Real Estate Landscape Post NAR Settlement

real estate landscape

The real estate landscape has been undergoing a seismic shift in the wake of the NAR settlement. This landmark event has cast a critical spotlight on long-standing practices, challenging traditional commission models and data-sharing protocols. 

Agents find themselves at a crossroads, compelled to reevaluate their approaches and seek innovative solutions that align with the evolving regulatory environment and the ever-changing needs of their clients. 

This guide is here to break down how the settlement affects your career, offering key insights to help you stay at the top of your game and thrive in today’s competitive environment.

NAR Reaches Landmark Settlement, Preserving Consumer Choice

The real estate industry has reached a pivotal juncture with the recent settlement between the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and the Department of Justice (DOJ). Subject to court approval, this agreement addresses long-standing concerns surrounding the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) cooperative compensation model rule, introduced in the 1990s to promote buyer representation and consumer protection.

Under the terms of the settlement, NAR will pay $418 million over approximately four years, while steadfastly denying any wrongdoing in connection with the MLS Model Rule. This resolution is a testament to NAR’s commitment to finding a balanced approach that benefits both its members and American consumers.

Ushering in New Era of Transparency in the Real Estate Landscape

Central to this historic agreement is the implementation of a new MLS rule prohibiting offers of broker compensation on the MLS. While offers of compensation will no longer be communicated via the MLS, they will remain an option for consumers to pursue through negotiation and consultation with real estate professionals. 

This change strikes a delicate balance, recognizing the benefits of offers of compensation in making professional representation more accessible, decreasing costs for home buyers, increasing fair housing opportunities, and expanding the potential buyer pool for sellers, while aligning with state real estate laws that expressly authorize such practices.

NAR has committed to enacting a new rule that will require MLS participants working with buyers to enter into written agreements. This measure reinforces NAR’s longstanding encouragement of buyer brokerage agreements, ensuring that consumers have a clear understanding of the services, value, and associated costs provided by their real estate professionals. These transformative changes are set to take effect in mid-July 2024.

Pragmatism Prevails: NAR’s Path Forward and Commitment to Members

Nykia Wright, Interim CEO of NAR, emphasized the organization’s pragmatic approach, stating, “Ultimately, continuing to litigate would have hurt members and their small businesses. While there could be no perfect outcome, this agreement is the best outcome we could achieve in the circumstances. It provides a path forward for our industry, which makes up nearly one-fifth of the American economy, and NAR.”

Kevin Sears, NAR President, echoed this sentiment, underscoring the association’s unwavering commitment to serving its members and American consumers. “NAR exists to serve our members and American consumers, and while the settlement comes at a significant cost, we believe the benefits it will provide to our industry are worth that cost,” he said. 

real estate landscape

Post NAR Settlement Tips for Real Estate Agents 

Real estate agents nationwide are grappling with the implications of this settlement, pondering its impact on their daily operations and client interactions going forward. Burning questions include: Does this herald the demise of traditional commission structures? Will homebuyers now bear the burden of compensating their own buyer’s agents, adding to the financial strain of down payments and closing costs?

It’s confusing, right? The video below is going to break it all down and give you the 411 on how this NAR settlement is really going to affect real estate agents like yourself. No need to panic just yet – here you’ll get some much needed clarity.


How to Handle Commission Discussions Going Forward

Emphasize Your Value in the Current Real Estate Landscape

When chatting with your clients about the settlement, it’s crucial to showcase your value in every interaction with potential clients going forward. Start by making a detailed list of all the unique perks you bring to the table. Get specific. Then, figure out how to communicate the value of your expertise, knowledge, skills, connections, and resources to potential clients.

Your main goal is to show buyers and sellers why they need a real estate agent in general and why they specifically need you. One great way to do this is by posting the list on your website. This lets visitors see exactly what you offer and how it benefits them directly.

Also, think about doing a behind-the-scenes series on social media. Capture different parts of your daily real estate activities and share these videos with your audience. From setting up open houses to attending continuing education courses, show every aspect of your work that clients usually don’t see.

Discuss Payment Structures Upfront and In Detail

It’s imperative to have transparent conversations with sellers about the benefits of contributing to the buyer’s agent’s fee. Given that first-time buyers already face financial challenges when purchasing a home, sellers need to understand the implications of not covering the buyer’s agent fee. 

If competing listings offer to cover this fee, buyers are less likely to choose a listing that requires them to pay their agent out-of-pocket. Ultimately, buyers now wield more negotiating power when it comes to the buyer’s agent fee. They may propose alternative compensation structures, such as a flat fee for each home shown or for writing an offer. 

Under the new regulations, buyer’s agents cannot accept compensation exceeding what is stipulated in the written agreement with their buyers. Therefore, it’s crucial to establish clear terms with your brokerage regarding the compensation structures you’re willing to work with. Some brokerages may opt to offer service packages at varying price points for buyers moving forward.

Continue to Enhance Your Negotiation Skills

The recent NAR settlement news will likely embolden buyers and sellers to negotiate more aggressively. They may propose lower percentages, flat rates, or hourly fees. Therefore, ensure you’re equipped to navigate these negotiations effectively.

Stay abreast of industry trends and best practices, continually enhancing your negotiation skills and honing your ability to effectively communicate the value you provide. Attend workshops, seminars, or seek mentorship from seasoned professionals to refine your approach and gain insights into successful negotiation strategies.

Remember, the key to thriving in this landscape lies in your ability to consistently demonstrate your worth and foster trust with your clients. By being proactive, adaptable, and steadfast in your commitment to delivering exceptional service, you can effectively navigate these negotiations and emerge as the preferred partner for buyers and sellers as well as increase your real estate sales per year. 

real estate lanscape

Summary of Changes to the Real Estate Landscape Due to the NAR Settlement

  • Agents’ compensation details can no longer be published on the MLS, altering the practice of disclosing the buyer’s agent’s expected earnings.
  • Buyers now have the opportunity to negotiate directly with their agents regarding fees, as sellers retain the option to assist buyers with expenses, similar to a concession.
  • Buyers’ agents must establish a written agreement with their clients before initiating property showings. These agreements must explicitly outline the compensation terms agreed upon between the agent and buyer.
  • Existing Buyer Representation Agreements may require revisions to align with the new guidelines, subject to the requirements of brokers, local boards, or legal counsel.
  • MLS services no longer mandate REALTORS/brokers to subscribe to specific services, granting industry professionals greater flexibility and autonomy.

Regardless of where you are licensed, it’s important for real estate professionals to acquaint themselves with the new rules post-NAR settlement. To learn more about these changes, read another HomeJab article that highlights the importance of embracing digital media in the real estate landscape.

Stay in the loop with the latest real estate trends, photography insights, and exclusive promotions!

$25 off

Sign up for the HomeJab Weekly newsletter now and enjoy $25 off your first order as a bonus for new subscribers!

Please fill in your details, one of our experts will contact you shortly.